Peel and stick or traditional wallpaper: how to choose for your wall

Layered Blues, a painterly design available in Premium, Premium Textured and Peel & Stick
Layered Blues, a painterly design available in Premium, Premium Textured and Peel & Stick

Choose Peel & Stick if your wall is smooth, the room stays dry and you want to be able to take the wallpaper down again. Choose a paste-the-wall paper if the wall has some texture, the room gets humid, the design is going on a ceiling or you want it to stay for good. Each of our designs is available both ways, so the wall and the room decide while the design stays the same.

Three papers, one design

When people say traditional wallpaper, they mean a paper hung with paste. At Wallism that is Premium and Premium Textured. Premium is a matte non-woven paper. Premium Textured is a slightly heavier paper with a textured matte surface. Peel & Stick is a matte paper with a self-adhesive backing that goes up without paste.

The three have more in common than the names suggest. Each one is printed to your wall's measurements and delivered in numbered strips 19.3 inches wide, which are hung edge to edge without overlapping. All of them are PVC-free and made to resist fading in sunlight. The differences lie in how each paper is fixed and what it asks of the surface underneath.

How the three papers compare
Premium
Paste-the-wall
Premium Textured
Paste-the-wall
Peel & Stick
Self-adhesive
How it goes up
Paste on the wall
Paste on the wall
Self-adhesive backing
Surface
Smooth matte
Textured matte, slightly heavier
Smooth matte
Smooth walls
✓
✓
✓
Lightly textured walls
✓
✓
—
Ceilings
✓
✓
—
Bathrooms
Yes, if well ventilated and away from direct water
Yes, if well ventilated and away from direct water
No
Best for
Walls you plan to keep
Walls you plan to keep, with more surface character
Walls you may want to change
Price per square foot
Lowest of the three
In between
Highest of the three

When Peel & Stick is the right choice

Peel & Stick suits a wall you expect to change. That might be a rented apartment, a child's room that will look different in five years or a corner you have not quite decided on. If you rent and are unsure what you are allowed to do, ask your landlord before you order.

How popular it is depends a lot on the country. Over the past two years, about one in five of our orders from the US included Peel & Stick, compared with around one in ten in the UK and one in sixteen in France.

It is also the simpler project. You need no paste, bucket or roller, only a sharp knife, a straight edge, a level and a smoother. You peel the backing away about 10 inches at a time rather than all at once, and if a strip lands slightly wrong, you can carefully loosen it and set it again.

It does come with conditions. The wall has to be smooth, because the adhesive will not hold properly on orange peel, knockdown or other textured finishes. The paint has to be fully cured, which can take four to six weeks after painting depending on the type of paint, so check the can. And the room should not swing between dry and humid, which rules out bathrooms. Peel & Stick is not made for ceilings either.

Installed properly, it lasts at least five years. It is designed to come down again, but taking it down and putting it back up more than once shortens its life.

Samples come without the self-adhesive backing, so they show the color and the print but cannot tell you how Peel & Stick will hold. Checking the wall itself tells you more.

Layered Blues hung on a smooth, dry bedroom wall, running from the crown molding down to the baseboard A smooth, fully cured wall in a dry room is exactly where Peel & Stick performs best.
“
Think of it as removable rather than reusable.
Layered Blues on an open-plan kitchen wall above the countertop, set back from the sink and stovetop Premium and Premium Textured suit a kitchen wall that stays mostly dry, kept clear of direct splashes.

When paste-the-wall is the better choice

Paste-the-wall sounds like more work than it is. The paste goes on the wall rather than on the paper, so you hang each dry strip straight onto the pasted area and can slide it slightly sideways to line up the edge with the one before. On top of the Peel & Stick tools, you need paste made for non-woven wallpaper, a brush or roller and a bucket with a sponge.

Roughly six in seven of our orders over the past year were for Premium or Premium Textured. Choose one of them in these situations.

A lightly textured wall. Our paste-the-wall papers adhere to textured surfaces, although a smoother wall still gives a better finish. The design matters here too. A white or very pale background shows bumps more clearly than a darker or busier design. Popcorn texture is the exception, because its sharp points can show through and even tear the paper when you smooth it.

A bathroom or a kitchen. Premium and Premium Textured can be used in a well-ventilated bathroom or on a kitchen wall that stays mostly dry. Keep them out of the shower and away from the wall directly behind a sink or stovetop, where water and splashes reach the paper.

A wall that should last. For permanent installations and busy spaces with more wear, such as a store or a hallway in an office, we recommend paste-the-wall over Peel & Stick.

Premium or Premium Textured?

Once you have chosen paste, the remaining decision is the surface. Premium is smooth and matte. Premium Textured has a slightly textured matte surface on a slightly heavier paper. Around four in ten of our orders over the past year were for Premium Textured.

In our view, texture suits designs where you would expect to see a surface. Painterly brushwork, plaster and stone effects are good examples. On Layered Blues, where the brushstrokes themselves are part of the picture, a textured surface adds to the feeling of paint on a wall. A crisp graphic line or a photographic image can look cleaner on the smooth Premium.

The product page shows the price of all three papers for your exact wall once you enter the measurements.

Check the wall before you choose

Most of this decision depends on the surface, so look at it closely. In the evening, hold a flashlight flat against the wall and shine it sideways along the plaster. Bumps and ridges cast small shadows that you will not see in daylight.

If the shadows show texture, choose paste. If the wall is smooth, the paint has had a few weeks to cure and the room stays dry, Peel & Stick is a good fit.

Common questions

Can I use Peel & Stick in a bathroom? +

No. The room should not swing between dry and humid, which rules out bathrooms. Premium and Premium Textured can be used in a well-ventilated bathroom or on a kitchen wall that stays mostly dry. Keep them out of the shower and away from the wall directly behind a sink or stovetop, where water and splashes reach the paper.

Can Peel & Stick go on a ceiling? +

No, Peel & Stick is not made for ceilings. Premium and Premium Textured can go on a ceiling.

Can I take Peel & Stick down and put it back up? +

Installed properly, it lasts at least five years. It is designed to come down again, but taking it down and putting it back up more than once shortens its life.

Will a sample show me how well Peel & Stick holds? +

Samples come without the self-adhesive backing, so they show the color and the print but cannot tell you how Peel & Stick will hold. Checking the wall itself tells you more.